# Leadership in the Age of Permanent Disruption: The End of the Heroic CEO?

Author: Norbert Biedrzycki
Published: 2023-12-15
Language: en
URL: https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/leadership-in-the-age-of-permanent-disruption-the-end-of-the-heroic/
Summary: Last month the world watched the most unusual leadership crisis in recent corporate history. On 17 November, the board of OpenAI removed its CEO, Sam Altman. Within days, the overwhelming majority…

Last month the world watched the most unusual leadership crisis in recent corporate history. On 17 November, the board of OpenAI removed its CEO, Sam Altman. Within days, the overwhelming majority of the company's roughly 770 employees signed a letter threatening to leave unless the board reversed course. By 22 November, he was back and the board had been reshaped.

It is tempting to read this as a story about one exceptional leader. I think it is a story about something else: the gap between formal authority and the real distribution of trust in an organization. The board had the authority. The organization decided where its loyalty lay.

## The heroic model

Business culture has long been built around the image of the heroic CEO. The visionary who sees what others miss, makes the bold call and carries the company through. Annual reports, business magazines and executive compensation all reinforce it.

The appeal is understandable. Organizations under stress want a face and a single point of accountability. Disney's decision last year to bring back Bob Iger shows how strong that instinct remains.

## Why the model is under strain

The heroic model assumes that the most important knowledge can be held by one person. In a world shaped simultaneously by AI, geopolitics, energy, regulation and changing workforce expectations, that assumption no longer holds. No CEO can be the expert on all of it. The decisions that matter most require knowledge distributed across dozens of people.

This changes what strong leadership means. It moves from personal authority toward organizational leadership capacity: the ability of the whole system to make good decisions, including when the leader is not in the room.

## What the new model asks of leaders

Satya Nadella has described the cultural shift he tried to lead at Microsoft as moving from a culture of "know it alls" to "learn it alls", borrowing from Carol Dweck's research on growth mindset. That phrase captures much of what is changing.

**Intellectual humility.** The ability to say "I do not know" and to change one's mind in public without losing authority.

**Building other leaders.** The CEO's legacy is increasingly measured by the depth of the leadership bench, not by personal decisions.

**Creating alignment rather than issuing direction.** In complex organizations, the leader's most valuable output is shared understanding.

**Challenging one's own assumptions.** Surrounding oneself with people who disagree, and rewarding them for it.

This is not weaker leadership. It is harder leadership. The heroic model is in some ways easier: decide, announce, expect compliance. The alternative requires designing the conditions in which others make good decisions, and accepting that some of them will be decisions you would not have made.

## The governance angle

The events at OpenAI also carry a lesson for boards. An organization whose value depends heavily on one individual is carrying a concentration risk, just as a company dependent on a single customer is. Succession planning, distributed leadership and clear governance are not bureaucratic formalities. They are what make an organization resilient to its own leadership.

> *Leadership question: Is the strongest leader the person who makes the best decisions, or the person who builds an organization capable of making better decisions?*
