# Leading Through Uncertainty: The CEO as Chief Crisis Manager

Author: Norbert Biedrzycki
Published: 2020-06-15
Language: en
URL: https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/leading-through-uncertainty-the-ceo-as-chief-crisis-manager/
Summary: On 5 May, Brian Chesky sent a letter to Airbnb employees announcing that the company would let go of around 1,900 people, roughly a quarter of its workforce. Layoff letters are usually written by…

On 5 May, Brian Chesky sent a letter to Airbnb employees announcing that the company would let go of around 1,900 people, roughly a quarter of its workforce. Layoff letters are usually written by lawyers and read like it. This one explained the reasoning, admitted what management did not know, described in detail how departing employees would be supported, and ended with an apology for things leadership could not control. It circulated far beyond Airbnb and is now being used as a case study in what leading through a crisis looks like.

A few weeks earlier, Marriott's Arne Sorenson recorded a video message to employees. He was visibly unwell after cancer treatment, spoke plainly about the collapse in bookings and announced that he would take no salary for the rest of the year. Again, the message was not the numbers. It was the credibility of the person delivering them.

## The collapse of the planning model

Traditional leadership models rest on three assumptions: that the future can be forecast within a reasonable range, that plans can be cascaded, and that control comes from measuring performance against those plans.

In March all three failed at once. Budgets became fiction within a week. Forecasts were replaced by scenarios, and the scenarios changed every Monday. The CEO's role moved overnight from managing performance to managing uncertainty.

That is a different job. Managing performance rewards precision and consistency. Managing uncertainty rewards speed, transparency and the ability to change one's mind publicly without losing authority.

## Confidence without certainty

The most difficult balance this spring has been between decisive action and honesty about how little anyone knows.

Too much certainty and leaders lose credibility the first time reality contradicts them. Too much humility and the organization reads it as paralysis. People do not need their CEO to know when the crisis will end. They need to know that someone is making decisions, what those decisions are based on, and when they will be revisited.

Jim Collins described this tension years ago through the Stockdale paradox: retain faith that you will prevail in the end, and at the same time confront the most brutal facts of your current reality. In practice, I see it translated into a few concrete disciplines.

**Communicate more often than feels necessary.** In a crisis, silence is not neutral. It is filled immediately with rumor.

**Separate what is known, what is assumed and what is unknown.** Saying this explicitly builds more trust than any reassurance.

**Set decision checkpoints rather than fixed plans.** "We will review this in two weeks with these three indicators" is a more credible commitment than a twelve month plan nobody believes.

**Protect liquidity first.** Every other choice depends on having time, and cash buys time.

## What this means for boards

Boards are learning something too. In normal times the board's role is oversight. In a crisis it becomes support, challenge and occasionally a second pair of eyes on decisions that have to be made in days rather than quarters. The boards that work best right now meet more often, ask fewer presentation style questions and give management room to act.

The crisis is also revealing a gap in how we select leaders. We have spent decades promoting executives who are excellent at running predictable businesses. Very few have been tested in an environment where the plan is obsolete before it is approved. That capability will be worth a premium for years.

> *Leadership question: How do you lead with confidence when you cannot offer certainty?*
