# Podcast: Norbert Biedrzycki on smart cities, the sharing economy, blockchain…

Author: Norbert Biedrzycki
Published: 2017-09-12
Language: en
URL: https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/podcast-norbert-biedrzycki-on-smart-cities-sharing-economy-blockchain/
Summary: A conversation with Norbert Biedrzycki, who writes a blog about the technologies of the future. Norbert has been CEO of several large, mainly IT, companies and has now returned to McKinsey.

[Link to the podcast (in Polish)](http://biznesmysli.pl/norbert-biedrzycki-o-smart-city-shared-economy-blockchain/)

One day I was contacted by Vladimir, who runs the BiznesMyśli blog, whose main subject is artificial intelligence, its applications and its impact on us as people. He suggested doing an interview as a podcast. Below is the recording.

Vladimir introduces the subject of the podcast, presents me and starts asking questions. Below is a transcript of our conversation (translated from Polish), taken from Vladimir's blog with his permission:

**Vladimir:** We return to today's conversation, whose guest is Norbert Biedrzycki. He writes an interesting [blog](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/) in which he shares his thoughts on current topics related to the technologies of the future. Norbert has been CEO of several large companies, mainly in IT. He has now returned to McKinsey.

![Pic\_1 - Norbert Biedrzycki](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Pic_1-Norbert-Biedryzcki.jpg)

*Norbert Biedrzycki*

He has 20 years of experience in these areas, and it is clear that he takes an active interest in artificial intelligence, machine learning, big data and topics that are changing our world, such as blockchain and smart cities.

**During the interview, Norbert said:**

![Norbert Biedrzycki Artificial Intelligence\_1 - pol](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Norbert-Biedrzycki-Artificial-Intelligence_1-pol.png)

**Listen to the podcast (in Polish):**

<audio preload="none" controls="controls"><source type="audio/mpeg" src="https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Norbert-Biedrzycki-podcast-BiznesMysli-1.mp3?_=1"><a href="/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Norbert-Biedrzycki-podcast-BiznesMysli-1.mp3">https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Norbert-Biedrzycki-podcast-BiznesMysli-1.mp3</a></audio>

**Vladimir: Hi Norbert! Introduce yourself – tell us who you are, what you do and how it came about that you don't work? I mean the famous quote attributed to Confucius: "Choose a job you love, and you will never have to work a day in your life".**

Norbert: Hi, good morning! That is not quite true, but I really am not working right now. I have been in IT for about 20 years. I run projects, ventures, start-ups and investments, and I manage companies. For the last dozen or so years I have run various large IT companies in Poland and abroad. I will mention companies such as [Atos](https://atos.net/en/) in Poland, and before that [ABC Data](http://www.abcdata.com.pl/), [Sygnity](http://www.sygnity.pl/en), [McKinsey](http://www.mckinsey.com/) and [Oracle](https://www.oracle.com/index.html).

I am at an interesting moment right now, because I am changing jobs. A few weeks ago I resigned as CEO of Atos; in fact I am still there until tomorrow, and the day after tomorrow I start at another company. That is the professional side, but your question makes me reflect more broadly. So much is happening in the world, especially in the last few years, that it is completely redefining the IT industry.

As I remember the IT industry 10–15 years ago, companies usually implemented smaller, larger or medium-sized systems for large or smaller clients. A company would come in, estimate the cost of the project and then implement it. There were year-long implementations of core banking systems, implementations in the public sector that took more than a year, or ERP implementations. I remember that 10 years ago a year-long SAP implementation was nothing unusual. Now these projects are changing because of the dramatically changing pace of life, the changing time it takes to build new products and services, to deliver to customers what they expect, to deliver technological novelties. I can clearly see that it is all accelerating, even exponentially.

**As a result, IT has changed completely compared with 10–15 years ago.** A client can no longer be expected to wait a year for an ERP system – no, it has to be a few weeks, a few months. It has to be a very concrete product, a concrete solution to a business problem. **More and more new technologies are beginning to have a huge impact on society, and some of them are totally changing the environment we live in.** I will mention a few that we will probably talk about later: [artificial intelligence](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/what-a-machine-will-think-when-it-looks-us-in-the-eye/) and [machine learning](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/machine-learning-computers-coming-of-age/), which will certainly affect how we work, live and behave, and how people interact with each other and with machines. [Blockchain](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/what-is-blockchain-all-you-need-know/) and [cryptocurrencies](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/what-are-bitcoins-all-you-need-know/), which in my view are now revolutionising how the world's financial system is built and managed and how it will develop. Some people talk about [economy 2.0](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/blockchain-the-holy-grail-of-the-financial-system/) here. The [Internet of Things](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/iot-internet-of-things/) and [big data](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/big-data-new-player-in-sports-2/) – collecting data from various sensors into huge databases where it is stored, so that valuable information can later be extracted and analysed. There are many new trends that are totally changing the way we work.

**Back to IT: what counts now is solving the business problem quickly and efficiently, using Scrum, Kanban, DevOps. In general, clients expect one- or two-week sprints, not year-long or six-month implementations.** They are interested in building applications incrementally, where they can see what is happening, watch and communicate with the team on an ongoing basis to solve a very specific business problem.

There was a joke going round the IT industry 10 years ago that, as ordinary people, we use 20% of Excel and Word but pay for 100%. No client expects 100% now; everyone wants the 20% that solves their specific problems. Sorry for the rather long introduction, but that is what I do, what I want to do and the direction in which the world is changing.

What will I be doing now? From 1 September I am moving – **in fact returning – to McKinsey, where I will be responsible for McKinsey Digital in this part of the world**. That is the part of McKinsey that solves clients' problems with technology. It usually looks like this: we have strategic projects, for example building a product or a product strategy for a financial institution.

After such a strategic project, when the consultants leave the client, the problem usually arises of how to implement it. Then IT usually says: "Mr President, we need a year to implement this banking product in our systems." Marketing says: "Oh dear, we need six months to design the marketing campaign; maybe we'll have it in six months."

For example, in an insurance company the actuaries need at least a few weeks to define it, and so on. Very often people from outside, who can come in without all the baggage of internal technology, legacy and politics, find it much easier to implement such a product or service. That is where McKinsey Digital comes in: using various technologies to solve clients' needs, tailor solutions and implement them quickly.

Sometimes a bit dirty, sometimes not entirely elegant, but so that the problem defined for that client is implemented quickly. That is it in short… Sorry for the somewhat lengthy exposé.

**Vladimir: I begin every podcast by saying that the world is changing faster than you think. You have just backed that up with several arguments. Now the conventional question: what book have you read recently, and why is it worth reading?**

Norbert: A very good question! Unfortunately I see, and it pains me, that people are stopping reading books. Someone once said – I don't remember who, but I will paraphrase – that reading books is important because you cannot reach every valuable person in the world directly; it is simply impossible. **But those people have put their thoughts, ideas, impressions and emotions on paper. And that paper is an intermediary, a way to reach that person, the great figures of this world or the people who interest us.**

I read a lot of books; I try to read a great many. I start some, read two or three at once, don't finish some, return to others. I read all kinds of books.

Back to your question, after another long introduction. I will mention two books I read recently. One was [Deep Work](http://amzn.to/2faZWvB) by Cal Newport, and the other a book from about 15 years ago – Michio Kaku's [Einstein's Cosmos](http://amzn.to/2wRU2sJ).

![](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Screen-Shot-2017-09-12-at-09.30.06.png) ![](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Screen-Shot-2017-09-12-at-09.29.40.png)

Why the first book? In it, the author puts forward what is in fact a very simple thesis. Roughly, it is **that amid the flood of information coming at us, the informational noise, it is very hard to a) choose the right information, b) digest and absorb it, c) learn it and d) respond to it in some way.** "Deep work" is something we did as students: to put it briefly, shutting yourself in a room and concentrating without a break for an hour or two. It is about valuable work and learning.

Remember that we are constantly bombarded by messaging apps, information, emails and news. All this distracts us and makes our concentration very low and short-term. Our brain is very plastic and is shaped this way: when we are bombarded with information, we often cannot focus for long on one area or issue. This book is about why it is worth doing – why such deep concentration, deep thinking and deep work are much better than constantly breaking away from one topic to another.

In a way it is about returning to how we studied and worked a dozen or so years ago – as I did at university. A very simple thing, really, but eye-opening… Most often we already know all the good things; at the end of the day we just have to reinvent them, so to speak.

The second book, [Einstein's Cosmos](http://amzn.to/2wRU2sJ), is old, about 15 years. It was written by Michio Kaku, a Japanese-American futurist and scientist. His books are worth reading. **This one is about quantum physics and how it affects us.** Why this book? Because about two years ago I became interested in quantum computers, quantum physics and how it and quantum computation – some say quantum computing – will affect us in the future. It is something new. So this book is more along IT lines.

**Vladimir: Artificial intelligence is a very hot topic now. Many people talk about it, but it must be admitted that AI is shown from one side only – and the bad side at that. The media usually focus on the negative aspects. That is easy to explain: the popularity of the channel matters, and people pay attention to negative things.**

**From where I stand, you seem to be one of the few people on the Polish internet who tries to draw attention to the positive aspects of artificial intelligence. You give concrete examples of where AI can really help us as humanity. Perhaps we could expand on that. How do you see it? How can artificial intelligence help people?**

Norbert: It is true that we are flooded with frightening reports about how computers, robots, machines, autonomous vehicles and artificial intelligence will soon take our jobs. To paraphrase Ray Kurzweil, in 2045 we will have a superintelligence that will decide what to do with our species. And the decision may be negative for us.



Ray Kurzweil: The Coming Singularity

I would say this: if we do not secure our position as a civilisation, there may be negative consequences. But a great many positive things are happening that are worth noticing.

I will give a few examples that I think are the most valuable and current. We collect huge amounts of data; this data floods us, and as people we are unable, without assistance – without either artificial intelligence or other methods such as machine learning and deep learning – to extract the right, valuable information from it in any way.

For example, **IBM's Watson is very effective at recognising from X-ray images whether an organ or tissue is affected by cancer** or healthy. IBM Watson has been trained and analyses data – in this case images – much more effectively than people. We are talking about 98% accuracy for the computer versus 92% for a radiologist. That is a few percentage points, but on a huge scale it means hundreds of thousands of correct diagnoses. The good news for cancer patients is that diagnoses can be made much more effectively. The negative news, of course, is that IBM Watson is better than a human. What will happen to the radiologists and doctors who now examine patients and make diagnoses?

Another example is **managing the ecosphere – how, using artificial intelligence, we can limit our negative impact on the planet we live on**. Not simple things like sorting rubbish, but how we use natural resources, how we prioritise our actions, how we optimise production processes so as to "squeeze more efficiently" from the resources we have.

**Vladimir: I would like to take the opportunity to ask you a few big-picture questions. Back to your blog, which I also recommend – I will quote it. You [wrote](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/technology-putting-pressure-business/) there that:**

![Norbert Biedrzycki changes\_2 - pol](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Norbert-Biedrzycki-changes_2-pol.png)

**…where you cover three topics: blockchain, the sharing economy and Industry 4.0. Please explain briefly what they are about. We will point interested listeners to the link in the notes. For now, just set out the context.**

**You named the three biggest revolutions we are seeing right now, which will change the way we live, work and learn: blockchain, the sharing economy and Industry 4.0.**

Norbert: I will take them in order. [Blockchain is a technology](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/blockchain-czyli-ostateczny-krach-systemu-finansowego/) which, in my view, together with the changes that follow it, will totally remodel the financial system we see today.

What characterises today's financial system? We have **central institutions – banks, central banks, clearing houses, payment systems – which manage the network instead of us**. In effect, we have to trust people, companies and algorithms we do not know and will never know to transfer, pay out and manage our money. **Blockchain, as a shared ledger available to everyone – peer-to-peer finance – changes the status quo and means that central institutions will no longer be needed.**

We can already make transfers using cryptocurrencies, of which there are more than 1,000. [Ten of them](http://www.hongkiat.com/blog/hottest-cryptocurrencies-to-know/) lead in terms of market capitalisation, with BTC accounting for 45% of the total. **We can make transfers in fractions of a second, for reasonably small amounts of money, from anywhere in the world** without central institutions. In my view, blockchain will totally demolish the financial ecosystem we see today. The key question is: will banks collapse? No, because banks will join in. Banks can see what is coming.

The digital banks of the future will either retreat to the role of clearing houses or join the revolution and take part in it. **What will this mean for us? First, the demolition of the existing financial market. Second, faster transactions for much lower fees than today, in seconds, all over the world.** Of course there is the question of how long it takes to mine the blocks, but in general we are talking seconds or minutes – ultimately probably seconds. **Third, new jobs will be created, and the whole working environment in the banking sector will be forced to change.** Fewer people in banking, more in technology.

Next, following the technologies you mentioned: **[the sharing economy](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/technology-putting-pressure-business/)**. Look at it this way: Uber is the largest taxi company without owning a single taxi. Airbnb is the largest accommodation company without a single hotel, guesthouse or even bed. That is the sharing economy – instead of owning a car, I can rent it, borrow it, share it with my neighbours or anyone else.

What does that lead to? **A car that I drive to work in the morning and use on average 1–1.5 hours a day does not stand in a car park in the new economy; it is in constant use.** Potentially, we can make use of everything we own at home, at work, in a company.

As a result, the way companies design products for this sharing-economy model will change completely. The way we use them will change, and so will the way we pay for these products or services. It affects us as people through much wider access to these services, and at a lower price. And again it breaks the status quo of existing businesses and service models.

Then **[Industry 4.0](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/end-of-the-world-we-know-welcome-the-digital-reality/)** – a very broad subject, which I will boil down to this: it is **a response to the individual needs of the customer**. Designing a product and service for the individual consumer. For example, the mobile phones we have – each could be completely different, with different features. It is also tracking the whole chain, from extracting raw materials through product components, manufacturing and delivery of the service.

**A model example of Industry 4.0 is the way industries are changing.** Tyre makers used to make tyres and deliver them to distributors, who sent them out into the world. I believe Michelin now [offers a service](http://www.tractionnews.com/the-internet-of-tires-is-coming/) in which every truck tyre has a beacon that continuously informs the vehicle owner or company about the tyre's wear. Based on this information, when a tyre wears out, Michelin can send a team to change it anywhere in the world, wherever the truck happens to be. Why do I mention this? Because it is a new service Michelin offers – not just selling a tyre, but **the tyre as a service**.

**Vladimir: As you can see, many things are changing. We are at the moment of a so-called paradigm shift. Let me add the example of autonomous cars. I mentioned in the [third](http://biznesmysli.pl/sztuczna-inteligencja-i-ekonomika-podcast-3/) episode that Google's brand [Waymo](https://waymo.com/) has driven more than 2 million kilometres in autonomous mode.**

**We can say that technically, with some exceptions, we are ready. But many other questions arise, for example: who will own the car? Who will insure it? When something bad happens, who will be to blame? And many other things. Share your opinion – what do you think?**



Are we ready for driverless cars? | Lauren Isaac | TEDxSacramento

Norbert: Another very good question. It is a huge subject. It concerns **[the ethics of autonomous vehicles](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/forbes-will-robots-begin-sin-humanity-will-soon-have-make-unequivocal-decisions/), machines and devices**. It is a subject that has fascinated me a lot recently. What if a machine has to make a decision that will be negative for the participants in an event? You raised several issues. I would say this: I doubt that – perhaps not my children yet, but my children's children – **will need a driving licence. Why would they?** Now another question: who will own the car? An insurance company? A leasing company? The individual consumer? Who will own the car, and will they need to own one at all? In the age of the sharing economy, I strongly doubt it.

Now the fundamental question of **the morality of machines – a textbook case you can read about everywhere online.** Say we are travelling in an autonomous car, reading a book, and suddenly a truck pulls out of a side road. The car can make two decisions: either it goes straight on, hits the truck and potentially kills us – the algorithm calculates that probability – or it swerves into the other lane, where a group of children is walking.



The Social Dilemma Of Driverless Cars | Iyad Rahwan | TEDxCambridge

**What decision should the car make? Or rather, what decision did the company that programmed it make? Or the programmer who built the algorithm? Or the designer – the "teacher" of artificial intelligence? And who is responsible?**

There are different methods. You can calculate the probability of an event statistically. The debate goes on. Some car companies say they will defend their owner at all costs and decide in favour of the passenger. Other companies, for example Mercedes and Volvo, have said that in such events they take responsibility for incidents resulting from their vehicles' decisions – not the insurer, not the leasing company, but the manufacturer. **The fundamental question is the moral problem of programming these machines.** How do you program them to make the "right" decisions, when the definition of right means something different to everyone? And who will be responsible? These are extremely difficult, even philosophical dilemmas.

I recently listened to a podcast on this subject – a debate between people from Tesla, Google, Mercedes and one other company. They were throwing philosophical dogmas at each other, quoting various philosophers on how it should be solved. It is a great subject. Personally, I am not sure I would feel comfortable sitting in a car and letting it make decisions for me. I think I would prefer some control over the car. Even if it drives autonomously, I would rather keep my hands on the wheel.

How will this interesting issue be resolved? I don't know, but I will give an example of how one company ran tests. I don't want to say which one, because I believe it is internal information. The question was: **how do you program a machine to make such decisions?** As in my example: do we crash head-on into the truck and potentially kill the passenger? Or do we swerve into the right lane and run over a group of children? The answers vary.

People from the companies that were in discussion lean towards the view that **moral costs should be taken into account. But how do you define them?** Another example: one of these companies said these difficult decisions were not made by the machine. They were programmed on the basis of live situations – the reactions of people who sat at the wheel of a virtual car and had to make such decisions. In the end, **it was calculated statistically how the system should behave and what decision it should make, based on statistical data from the reactions of real drivers**.

Another company used computer games. Real drivers were sat in front of a game and had to resolve such dilemmas. I don't know which answer is right; it is all still ahead of us. I know that cars are about to hit the road in California, and from 1 January autonomous trucks will be driving some routes in Germany. It will be interesting.



What a driverless world could look like | Wanis Kabbaj

**It really does sound interesting if autonomous trucks will already be driving in Germany. Let's move on to [smart cities](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_city). Explain what one is and give a real-life example that everyone can understand.**

How It Works: Smarter Cities

Norbert: In general, **a [smart city](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/sagrada-familia-and-the-internet-of-things/) is a city friendly to its residents that uses all kinds of technologies to make people's lives more pleasant**. A model example is a system of car parks on the outskirts of the city. A resident drives to one, guided by a system that suggests a particular space. Then, on a single ticket and using various means of public transport, they travel to the centre or to their workplace.

Thanks to a so-called electronic wallet, they can buy various city services: pay for tickets, borrow books, register with a doctor. In short, it is a city that is friendly to people through the use of diverse technologies. Flagship examples are Singapore, New York and Prague – places in the ranking of the most technologically advanced cities that are approaching the smart city model.

**Vladimir: We now know what a smart city is; to make it more tangible, let's talk numbers. The information comes from the IESE Cities in Motion Index 2017 [report](http://citiesinmotion.iese.edu/indicecim/?lang=en), which analysed 180 key cities worldwide. From Poland it chose Warsaw and Wrocław – I don't know why those cities. Warsaw is understandable, but why Wrocław and not, say, Kraków, Gdańsk or Poznań? It is not entirely clear to me, but never mind.**

![](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Pic_2-Cities.png)

IESE ranking

**Wrocław came 95th and Warsaw 54th out of 180, Berlin 9th, Paris 3rd, and New York 1st. My question relates directly to Poland. You have held CEO positions at various companies and you see the broader context of how smart cities are developing. Tell us, as far as you can – since you can't talk about everything – how Polish cities will change over the next 5 or 10 years.**

Norbert: Within the next three years, by 2020, there will be more than 80 megacities in the world, understood as cities with more than 30 million inhabitants. Why? Because statistically, around 300,000 people migrate from rural areas to cities every day worldwide.



What are Smart Cities? | Larissa Suzuki | TEDxUCLWomen

**The first trend is migration, and the second is ageing societies. How do we care for older people in these cities? The third trend is growing consumption – not only of electricity, but of resources.** These are trends that have to be managed. Now to our Polish backyard. I am sometimes controversial in my opinions. A few months ago I spoke about smart cities at a conference for city leaders.

I put forward the thesis that in our Polish idea of a smart city, the dream model is a city that lets you find a parking space with your smartphone, drive to it and pay for it by phone. For many of our city leaders that is the end state; for me it is the beginning. I also raised a controversial point that everyone thought about and then agreed with. It was that by building autonomous car parks around cities and putting technology behind renting spaces, we may be solving the wrong problem. Because if we take the sharing economy and autonomous cars seriously, perhaps we do not need to build more car parks at all? In 5–10 years we will need fewer of them. So not car parks, but the sharing economy. Back to your question. **Poland is developing; it is very clear that local governments are investing in various technologies to make cities user-friendly, so that residents can make decisions with the help of different technologies.**

Decisions about what their surroundings, community and the place they live in should look like. It is not only about influencing votes and decisions, but also about fundraising, and influencing what mobile and smartphone apps look like, so they have the features that matter most to me as a resident. In Russia, a trend was once started in which the users of an area – its residents – should decide what the area looks like.

Parks used to be designed by simply laying paths, and that was it. But that Russian designer said: wait until winter, when the snow falls and people tread paths between the trees. Translating that idea to today, **the smart city idea means that residents decide what the city will look like and how technology will support them in everyday life** – and that is really great.

It is not as it used to be, when the mayor made decisions on a whim; people make these decisions, and that is really great. The electronic wallet is an amazing thing! It is a card that lets you find your way around various city services and order them. It is a mix of a bank card, parking card, library card and doctor's card. One card serving everything, a bit like in The Lord of the Rings: "one to rule them all".

**Vladimir: That story about the paths is very interesting. I think it was said by [Sergei Korolev](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergei_Korolev), who designed spacecraft.**

**You raised an interesting point: that smart cities and similar projects we talked about today, such as artificial intelligence, should exist to help people. That thread is often overlooked; questions are asked from a different angle – not to help someone directly, but to try to solve a problem that may no longer exist in 5–10 years. I am thinking of the parking example you mentioned.**

Norbert: Perhaps we are solving the wrong problems altogether? Wrongly framed theses.

**Vladimir: Exactly. Now a question about my motivation for this podcast. Its target audience is often decision-makers who want to get started with machine learning but don't quite know how. How would you persuade such people?**

**Why is now the moment to get involved? What benefits will they miss if they don't bring machine learning and new technologies into real life now, but keep putting it off until the proverbial tomorrow?**

Norbert: It's a bit like a bus pulling away: if you don't get on, you are left at the stop. Machine learning is a technology that will change the way we live. Look at what is happening in the world now, especially in business. Customers expect things faster, faster, faster and cheaper, cheaper, cheaper. They expect a service to be done, delivered and completed faster – remember my example of ERP implementations at the beginning of our conversation – and cheaper and more tailored to their needs. If it is to be cheaper, unfortunately it cannot be done with people. You may not know that the level of product segmentation and customer segmentation in a typical e-commerce business, just 5 years ago, covered several hundred to several thousand end-customer segments.

**Now segmentation and behavioural data define services and products dedicated to a single individual. No human can handle that amount of data.** Data on how customers react to our products, what they need, how they rate products – and then add social media. There is a huge amount of information, which is why machine learning comes in: a technology that lets us decide, on the basis of huge amounts of data from different sources, what to offer a given customer and how, so that they buy from us, come back and stay with us rather than the competition. It is a matter of efficiency.

Look at **how Amazon suggests certain books and products based on your purchase history.** That was a long time ago already. **Look at how Facebook searches and suggests on a user's wall what is worth reading, based in fact on behavioural patterns.** You can multiply such examples.

What I am saying is that it is a dedicated offer for the individual consumer – for me personally, not for a whole segment. For me individually, based on my behaviour and huge amounts of data. It's a bit like that bus: either we get on or we stay at the stop, and whoever has it will simply eat us.

**I wouldn't be afraid of artificial intelligence, algorithms or networks. These** are very simple things. Neural networks can be built with software available today. Two examples: Google offers [TensorFlow](https://www.tensorflow.org/) as open source, and Elon Musk and his foundation [OpenAI](https://openai.com/) also share their experience, showing that the technology is not that complicated. Programmers are learning how to do it. Building an artificial intelligence on my Mac is a matter of a few days. Building a simple network that makes or proposes some decisions is not rocket science. The building blocks can be downloaded and used right now. Of course there are specialised companies that do this, whose services you can use, and I recommend doing so. For me it is a no-brainer: the world is heading this way, and either we get on the train or we stay on the platform.

**Vladimir: A related question, but from a different angle. We know that most of the professions we know now will not be practised by our children, and certainly not by our grandchildren. That means people will start losing jobs; new jobs will appear, but people will have to adapt. What advice can you give employers and employees? How can we make this transition as painless as possible?**

Norbert: It is not going to happen in one day. Take the example of autonomous trucks. It is not as if all the drivers will get up one Tuesday morning, go to work, find beautiful new autonomous trucks standing there and have no jobs. I have read studies saying this is a process spread over the next 20 years. I wouldn't demonise it. But the trend is clearly visible already, and people are reacting to it. Here is an example. **Artificial intelligence is far more effective than a human lawyer at proposing certain legal solutions.** It solves legal tasks faster and more effectively than a lawyer – but only very simple things, such as contracts and agreements.



Should We Let Robots Take Our Jobs?

**As a result, far fewer people are now applying to law schools in the United States.** But specialised lawyers in M&A ([mergers and acquisitions](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mergers_and_acquisitions)) and [due diligence](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Due_diligence) will still be needed, because the complexity of cases keeps growing. Back to the example of IBM Watson recognising the stage and progression of cancer from images. **It is not as if all radiologists will lose their jobs tomorrow. It will be a process spread over time.** In this case, it will be better for patients: diagnoses will be made more effectively.

Trucks? Definitely safer, faster and cheaper. Many new professions will arise. **A profession that is emerging now and will be intensively promoted is the teacher of artificial intelligence.** Someone will have to program them. Of course there are technologies and techniques that make it possible to transfer parts of neural networks from one machine to another, but teaching them new things is a profession that will grow.

**The artificial intelligence trainer is a profession of the future. The professions that are disappearing are, as I said, lawyers, drivers and, in the long run, accountants and so on. Jobs that require repetitive, clearly defined tasks will certainly be taken over by machines. Jobs that require creativity, a different way of looking at things and empathy will certainly grow. The trend is that people who serve others in complicated matters will definitely be needed, not least because of emotional intelligence.**



What will future jobs look like? | Andrew McAfee

**As potential employees, we should watch the labour market.** I would put it this way: the paradox is that everyone now wants to be a programmer. It seems to be the profession of the future. But given the increasing automation of code-writing, **in the future the world will not need nearly so many programmers.** Of course they will be needed for highly specialised, complex tasks, but those who translate system architecture and user requirements into code – which is in effect 80% of programmers – will not be needed. Machines will do it themselves. **Advice? Watch what is happening and keep learning, all the time, throughout your life. Reading books, self-improvement and learning are what we should do constantly in order to always be a step ahead.**

**Vladimir: That is great advice. I think one thing is worth stressing. I agree that it won't happen in a day; it will take time – 5, 10 or 20 years. But we often think it will happen "some day", and then it turns out that "some day" has just arrived today.**

**We get caught up in the whirl of ordinary days, constantly repeating the same activity, and because we don't develop, at some point we collide with reality and the market says that what we can do is no longer needed, because there is a machine that does it better. I agree 100% that it is worth starting to learn now rather than waiting, because it really will all be fully deployed in 15 or 20 years.**

Norbert: Let me add something. Assuming that **[machines take over our various](https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/work-of-the-future-reinventing-work/) professions, the labour market will change dramatically.** This debate is going on around the world among economists and in the EU.

Proposals such as a guaranteed basic income are very topical and widely discussed. A concept is being tested that guarantees residents a basic monthly income, mainly so that they can survive or study. Whatever they earn on top is theirs. Whether the experiment succeeds, tests will show in a few years. I strongly believe we must find some equivalent for supporting these social groups.

**Will it be a guaranteed basic income? Or – wait for it – taxing robots?** Following that line of thought: robots take our jobs, so as workers we pay less tax to the state, and the state apparatus, to simplify greatly, is funded by taxes on companies and people. **The state will have trouble funding itself, so perhaps robots' work should be taxed?**



Why we should give everyone a basic income | Rutger Bregman | TEDxMaastricht

Another idea smacks a little of socialism: **guaranteed employment.** Introducing a legal mechanism that would force employers to guarantee employment to workers from certain social groups. It sounds like science fiction. I am not convinced about the last one, but these ideas – guaranteed basic income, taxing machines or guaranteed employment – are still being discussed and tested.

**Guaranteed basic income will probably win,** especially as tests of the idea are being run around the world. In any case, we will certainly have to provide some basic minimum so that people can survive in some way. **Assuming, of course, that the thesis "robots are taking our jobs" is true and that we will not be able to retrain quickly for new professions.** I have written an article on this for my blog and will publish it shortly – what exactly it is and how these ideas clash. A bit of a plug – I recommend it!

**Vladimir: Thank you, I will also leave a link to that article once it appears, and I encourage everyone to read it. Norbert, what can I wish you?**

Norbert: There is a Chinese curse: "May you live in interesting times." What should I wish for? I wish myself and all of you – all of us – that we can find our way in this new future, among the technologies around us and the different market models, and remain happy people. To be centred, to find that passion – that is the long term. In the short term, I would wish myself and you that we read books. Books record the ideas of people we will never have access to in everyday life. That is what I wish myself, all of you and you!

**Vladimir: Thank you, great advice. I wish that each of us read more. Perhaps it is worth adding that it is not about turning pages but about reflecting. Sometimes I see an extreme: people say "read", but they don't really explain what that means. It is not about buying books and flicking through pages, but also thinking about what you have read.**

Norbert: Yes, yes. **Read with understanding**, or as someone says: "Did you hear? I heard, but I didn't listen." So read with understanding, draw conclusions from it, think for yourself. That is very good. Amid the flood of data we are drowning in, take nothing for granted. **Draw your own conclusions, think for yourself based on books and ideas, and build your own opinions on that basis.** It is so easy to manipulate public opinion on social media. It is easy to buy a gazillion votes on Facebook or Instagram promoting some service or product. **It is worth thinking and drawing your own conclusions.**

**Vladimir: How can people find you online? Where are you active on the internet?**

Norbert: I am available on this blog. Of course I can't reply to everyone. Various discussions take place on the blog. I am available there; if anyone has valuable comments or a topic, or wants an intellectual sparring match with me, come to the blog. I have a LinkedIn page and a public Facebook page, where I try to reply regularly. I am available – you are welcome there.

**Vladimir: Thank you, Norbert, for a great conversation, and I wish you success in your new job!**

Norbert: Thank you – thank you and your listeners. I wish your podcast continues to grow, and I look forward to listening to the next episodes.

Published with Vladimir's permission.

[Link to the article](http://biznesmysli.pl/norbert-biedrzycki-o-smart-city-shared-economy-blockchain/) with the podcast (in Polish)
