# The Transformation Imperative: Why Incremental Change Is No Longer Enough

Author: Norbert Biedrzycki
Published: 2023-10-15
Language: en
URL: https://norbertbiedrzycki.pl/en/the-transformation-imperative-why-incremental-change-is-no-longer/
Summary: On 2 May, Chegg's share price fell by roughly half in a single day. The company, which sells homework help to students, told investors that ChatGPT was affecting its growth. Six months after…

On 2 May, Chegg's share price fell by roughly half in a single day. The company, which sells homework help to students, told investors that ChatGPT was affecting its growth. Six months after OpenAI released a chatbot to the public, a listed company had lost half of its market value because of it.

A few weeks ago, on 29 September, Netflix mailed its last DVD. The business that founded the company was shut down by the company itself, years after streaming had started to cannibalize it. Netflix did not wait for a competitor to make the DVD obsolete. It did it on its own terms.

These two stories frame the leadership question of 2023 better than any framework.

## The limits of improvement

For most of the last decade, transformation meant improvement. Digitize the process, automate the back office, move to the cloud, make the customer journey smoother. All valuable. All incremental. All based on the assumption that the business model itself would remain intact.

That assumption is now under pressure in several industries at once. Generative AI is the most visible force, but not the only one. Higher capital costs are punishing models that only worked with cheap money. Energy prices have changed the economics of European manufacturing. Customer expectations formed during the pandemic have not reversed.

In industries undergoing structural change, getting ten percent better at the old model is not a strategy. It is a slower decline.

## Transformation versus reinvention

It helps to separate two words that are often used interchangeably.

**Transformation** improves how an organization operates. Same customers, same value proposition, better execution.

**Reinvention** questions whether the organization should operate in the same way at all. Different value proposition, different revenue model, sometimes different customers.

Most companies are good at the first and avoid the second. Clayton Christensen explained why a quarter of a century ago. The existing business is profitable, measurable and defended by the people who run it. The new one is uncertain, small and threatens the old one. Rational managers, acting rationally, protect the core until it is too late. Kodak is the textbook case. Fujifilm, facing the same collapse of film, reinvented itself into healthcare, materials and cosmetics, and survived.

## The hardest part: running two companies at once

The real difficulty of reinvention is not the vision. It is managing the transition. The existing business still pays the salaries. It must keep performing while part of the organization builds something that may eventually replace it.

This requires a different kind of leadership discipline. Separate metrics for the core and for the new. Protected investment that is not cut in the first bad quarter. Leaders for the new business who are not judged by the logic of the old. And a CEO and board willing to explain to shareholders why they are funding something that will reduce today's earnings.

Netflix managed this over more than a decade. Most companies will not get that much time.

> *Leadership question: When does improving the existing business become less valuable than fundamentally reinventing it?*
