NORBERT BIEDRZYCKI

The Middle Management Paradox: The Most Important and Most Underestimated Layer of Transformation

The Middle Management Paradox: The Most Important and Most Underestimated Layer of Transformation

In April, Gallup published its annual State of the Global Workplace report. Global employee engagement fell from 23 to 21 percent last year, with an estimated cost to the world economy of 438 billion dollars in lost productivity. The most striking finding was where the decline came from. Engagement among individual contributors stayed flat at 18 percent. Engagement among managers fell from 30 to 27 percent. Young managers and female managers saw the steepest drops.

At the same time, many large companies are reducing management layers. Last September Amazon’s Andy Jassy told employees the company would increase the ratio of individual contributors to managers by at least 15 percent by the end of the first quarter of 2025. Meta made flattening a central theme of its 2023 “year of efficiency”. The phrase “the Great Flattening” has entered the business press.

Put these trends together and you see the paradox. Organizations are asking more of middle managers than ever, while cutting their numbers and their support.

Where transformation actually happens

Senior executives define strategy, approve investments and communicate priorities. Frontline employees experience the change in their daily work. Between them sits the layer that determines whether a strategy becomes reality.

Middle managers translate strategy into team priorities. They keep current operations running while new ones are built. They handle the anxiety that every change creates. They resolve the conflicts between competing initiatives. They decide, in hundreds of small daily choices, whether the new way of working is taken seriously.

Gallup has estimated for years that around 70 percent of the variance in team engagement is attributable to the manager. In transformation, I suspect the share is even higher.

Why they are underinvested

Executive transformation programs are well funded. Leadership offsites, strategy work, executive coaching. Frontline employees receive training on new tools. Middle managers often receive neither. They get a communication pack and a target.

They are also frequently given responsibility without authority. Expected to drive change in their teams but unable to change processes, budgets or staffing. Expected to motivate people through uncertainty while being uncertain about their own role in the flatter organization being designed above them.

In large organizations the effect compounds. A strategic decision passes through several management layers before it reaches the team that executes it. Every layer that does not understand or believe in it reduces its strength.

Flattening without hollowing

I am not arguing against fewer layers. Many organizations have too many managers managing too few people, and the cost in speed is real. But removing layers and strengthening the remaining managers have to happen together.

Fewer managers, better equipped. Wider spans of control only work if managers have the tools, data and authority to lead larger teams.

Involve them in design, not only delivery. Managers who helped shape a change defend it. Managers who received it often wait it out.

Give them real decision rights. Budget flexibility, influence over staffing and the ability to adapt the plan locally.

Develop them seriously. Leading a team through AI driven change is a skill. Very few managers have been taught it.

Leadership question: Why do organizations invest so much in executive transformation programs while underinvesting in the managers who actually make transformation happen?

Read next

  1. Change Fatigue Is Becoming a Strategic Risk: Can Organizations Change Faster Than People Can Adapt?

    Transformation and Leadership series, written in 2026

  2. The New Operating Model: Breaking Silos and Building Organizations Around Value Creation

    Transformation and Leadership series, written in 2026

  3. The Capability Gap: Why Skills, Not Strategy, May Be the Biggest Transformation Bottleneck

    Transformation and Leadership series, written in 2026