Can the world's largest stock exchanges benefit from blockchain?

My article in AntyWeb, 27 February 2019.
The rules of securities trading differ little from those that applied two or three centuries ago. Does such a strongly “preserved” system need to change, and can it be changed at all? How do you convince boards, investors, sellers, intermediaries and supervisory commissions to accept new solutions? And even if it became possible, would it be a serious step towards eliminating stock exchanges in their current form?
The stock exchange as a set of problems
Today’s investors use a traditional system of buying, selling and settling transactions that we have known for decades. It brings considerable costs and long settlement times. This is because several parties are involved in securities trading, forming a complex system of intermediaries, clearing systems and partners. Investors, brokers, custodians, the exchange’s management and central supervisory institutions – all participants in securities trading must keep updating records of transaction status on an ongoing basis, relying on traditional methods of exchanging information. Every purchase, sale and change of ownership generates its own messages and authorisations.
Blockchain gives us the opportunity to change this. Key processes related to transactions, such as the issuance of securities, trading, clearing and settlement, could take place using a distributed ledger.
The world after the crash
There is one more important issue. I mean trust, which includes the average investor’s faith (or lack of it) in the general rules governing the entire stock exchange system.
The 2008 crisis, the excessive “multiplication” of opaque financial instruments and the dishonesty of traders were a strong impulse to reflect on the transparency of the existing model. The crash we witnessed ten years ago encouraged us to think about alternatives that could help build a system that is transparent and resistant to manipulation. I believe the features of blockchain make it possible to think about a changed “stock exchange of the future”. There would be no place in it for dishonest intermediaries, and opaque transactions would become impossible. Smart contracts could remove doubts about whether settlements are correct. Perhaps supervisory mechanisms – necessary today, yet not entirely effective – would lose their reason to exist altogether.
Blockchain on the biggest trading floors
The investment market leads the pack when it comes to the first blockchain deployments.
For example, Nasdaq has been looking at the technology for three years. As early as May 2015 it launched a private trading platform called Linq, which allows companies not listed on the exchange to represent their shares digitally. In addition, together with the Swedish bank SEB, the exchange began testing a blockchain last year that would be used to record all transactions in real time. Blockchain-based solutions were also tested intensively at Nasdaq Tallinn: the project allows investors holding shares to cast their votes at shareholder meetings or to transfer their voting rights to a proxy. The London Stock Exchange Group, in cooperation with IBM, decided to test a blockchain platform to fully digitise securities trading for small and medium-sized companies; the tests are being run by LSEG’s Italian operator, Borsa Italiana. In Australia, the Australian Securities Exchange plans to complete this year two years of work on a system designed to increase the transparency of operations and protect investors.

The Delaware initiative
One of the more interesting examples that blockchain can become a reality is the “Delaware initiative”. A year ago, the American state known for its high concentration of listed companies passed a law giving blockchain official status in the record-keeping system. State law that favours new solutions could revolutionise corporate record-keeping. The state authorities are building a system that allows companies to generate and store all their corporate data. Those who lobbied for blockchain in Delaware pointed to the complex nature of the securities market, especially tracking the ownership of shares. The initiators of the project argued that blockchain is a good solution that makes it easier to verify ownership and significantly shortens transaction times.
Security and energy
Given that blockchain is being considered for such a sensitive segment of the market as financial services, banks and related organisations must be sure that their clients’ funds are safe. We are only at the beginning of the road, and spreading blockchain in capital markets takes time. For real progress to be made, several conditions must be met. Above all, the highest security standards must be defined for block systems. Deploying blockchain requires regulation, which for now is fragmented and inconsistent. We must also remember the ongoing limitations of the technology itself, which is still working on increasing throughput and genuinely lowering transaction costs. Hundreds of thousands of operations are executed every day on the world’s major exchanges. Building new platforms to handle them can be complicated and lengthy, and that means costs. Nevertheless, I believe the most important deployments of this technology will be in financial markets, and stock exchanges may become a kind of testing ground for it.
Link to the article (in Polish).
Related articles


