NORBERT BIEDRZYCKI
6 min readPressRead this in Polish

Forbes: Should we regulate artificial intelligence, and how?

Forbes: Should we regulate artificial intelligence, and how?

My article in FORBES, 1 February 2020: Should we regulate artificial intelligence, and how?

There is a debate about how to regulate issues related to artificial intelligence. Lawyers, politicians and business people feel that existing legislation is not keeping up with the technological progress we are experiencing. In legal and statutory terms, it is not properly “served”. Can artificial intelligence be regulated effectively, and do we need that? Not only is the logic of algorithms hard for us to understand. As citizens, we also have no idea how modern technology is used by companies, institutions and security services to monitor our lives.

Shouldn’t we have a clear sense that when we use computers, drones, apps, cameras and social networks, we are protected? And that someone is making sure we never reach a situation in which algorithms choose a president for us?

I do not think that attempts to regulate artificial intelligence are a waste of anyone’s time or a restriction on the free flow of ideas or the functioning of business. A technology that begins to develop without our involvement, improving its performance without a programmer’s intervention, becomes a powerful force. Faced with it, the principle of unlimited business freedom seems somewhat archaic and does not solve many problems.

To regulate or not

Opinions on whether the development of autonomous, intelligent technologies should be regulated are, of course, divided. Elon Musk regularly expresses concern about the fate of our planet and believes we need strong mechanisms to protect people from technological threats. At the opposite pole is a supporter of a very liberal approach, Mark Zuckerberg (although he seems to have modified his views somewhat recently).

In general, we encounter different attitudes in American business circles than in Europe. The European Group on Ethics is working towards an international agreement and a legal framework for autonomous systems. In the group’s opinion, “autonomous systems must not impair the freedom of human beings (…) Artificial intelligence should contribute to global justice and equal access to the benefits that robotics and autonomous systems can bring.”

However, a radically different approach must also be noted in the case of China. In a country that wants to lead the development of artificial intelligence, it is treated as a basic tool for monitoring and controlling social behaviour.

Observation, education, dialogue

In a changing reality, experts in new technologies play an important role. An ordinary citizen may want to ask them: can we feel safe because “fair, transparent and accountable artificial intelligence” accompanies us in our lives? In this last sentence I am referring to the name of one of many seminars (Fair, Transparent, and Accountable AI) organised by the Partnership on AI. Its mission is precisely to study practices related to the presence of artificial intelligence in our lives and to explain to the public what is new in this area.

It is worth quoting the description of that event on the organisation’s website (partnershiponai.org): artificial intelligence can improve decision-making through techniques that draw conclusions from large amounts of data, and may lead to breakthroughs in areas such as safety, health, education, transport, sustainability, public administration and science; however, these potential benefits are accompanied by concerns among the public and specialists about the harm AI may cause.

Below I list four example areas (there are, of course, many more) that are undergoing rapid change under the influence of AI. Some of them may in time require special regulatory mechanisms so that we feel comfortable using the technology.

In conflict with the law

Algorithms are used by police forces all over the world. Artificial intelligence helps process data, including a lot of information related to crime, searches for missing persons and so on. The ability to classify objects (including photos) based on specific features is one of many advantages of machine learning, and it is certainly appreciated by all services that want to reach important information for an investigation quickly.

Unfortunately, situations in which algorithms assess the likelihood that a person will reoffend (which affects possible parole) can lead to abuse. That is why organisations set up by lawyers are already emerging around the world (for example, the Law Society’s Public Policy Technology and Law Commission), whose mission is to monitor the actions of the police and courts in this area.

Fake news, a universal plague

This is a hot topic that has been discussed a lot recently. It raises questions about the credibility of information and the responsibility of social networks for monitoring it. Since 2016, which was a turning point in the flood of fake news scandals, not a week has gone by without the issue being raised.

Artificial intelligence plays a part here, because, as we know, it has a large role in automatically generating content (bots). I think the credibility of information is one of the greatest challenges of our time, which could be called the era of disinformation. It definitely requires global reflection and even international cooperation. Initiatives for reliability appear from time to time (such as Elon Musk’s “Pravda”), but the matter is difficult. Regulation seems utopian here, so I do not know whether we are in for many more years of struggling with this problem.

See also: The war for the internet

Who rules the assembly line?

Robotisation in industry is one of the most emotionally charged aspects of artificial intelligence. We have a huge problem accepting that robots may become our colleagues at work (contributing to our unemployment). I have written about this many times, so I will not present data or arguments for or against robotisation here.

See also: Technology 2020. Printed food and microscopes inside our bodies

The problem obviously exists, and there is no point pretending it will go away. On the contrary, social unrest may grow as this trend develops. Because of the social consequences, setting rules in this area is extremely important. Tax mechanisms that discourage corporations from excessive robotisation could be used, for example.

Regulating self-driving cars?

Enthusiasts cite numerous studies showing that autonomous vehicles mean much greater road safety. I agree with this thesis. Nevertheless, autonomous vehicles raise questions. One of the basic ones concerns how the vehicle behaves in an accident.

Whom should algorithmic mechanisms protect in particular – passengers, drivers, pedestrians? Will a driver who causes an accident through a moment of inattention be able to sue the manufacturer of the autonomous vehicle with any hope of winning? How should vehicles be insured? Who is responsible for an accident: the driver, the passenger, the owner of the vehicle, the manufacturer or the team of programmers?

Another issue ahead of us is the future of other autonomous means of transport: aircraft, ships or cars that will provide transport services for us without anyone needing to sit behind the wheel (delivering shopping and so on). Legislation around the world differs in its approach to testing autonomous cars. Everywhere, however, there is a debate about how to increase the safety of their users.

Technology is for people

The progress made thanks to intelligent technology is indisputable. But I believe that, alongside business issues such as cost optimisation, efficiency, profitability and automation (all of which benefit from artificial intelligence), it is important to remember less measurable things: that our ordinary individual well-being, safety, knowledge and fulfilment in our contact with new technology are the most important values.

Technology is supposed to make our lives better. So let us watch closely the work of experts who shape legal systems that protect us from the undesirable actions of algorithms.

Link to the article (in Polish)

Related articles:

– Let us learn like machines, and even more

– It is time to talk to the machine

– Will algorithms commit war crimes?

– Machine, when will you learn to make love to me?

– When will we stop being biological humans?

– Artificial intelligence is the new electricity

– How machines reason

Read next

  1. Forbes: The dark side of AI. Can neural networks discriminate?

  2. Forbes: Technology 2020. Printed food and microscopes inside our bodies

  3. Forbes: Technology 2020. Algorithms in the cloud, the 5G revolution and seductive machines