NORBERT BIEDRZYCKI
4 min readPressRead this in Polish

Autonomous cars are overtaking our legal systems

Autonomous cars are overtaking our legal systems

My article published in Business Insider on 3 February 2019.

Autonomous machines, and above all autonomous vehicles on the roads, are another sign of the development of artificial intelligence. I follow news about the work of Tesla and the largest car manufacturers with great interest, because a transport revolution on our roads may become the most tangible proof that artificial intelligence is something concrete, not a set of abstractions known only to programmers.

As with labour law and copyright, the legal issues here are becoming increasingly complex. The notion of legal liability for an autonomous vehicle on the road is particularly interesting. Here it does not take much imagination to foresee problems in assigning legal responsibility for accidents.

An autonomous car causes an accident

In the event of a collision, a dangerous situation or even a death, who becomes the subject of a dispute, a possible lawsuit or a claim for compensation? Who should bear the main responsibility when people die in an accident involving autonomous vehicles? Will the developer of the algorithm that drives the car be in trouble, the company that produces the car, or the driver who owns it? And if the owner causes an accident, can they count on insurance arrangements good enough to use the car with peace of mind?

This example clearly shows that technological possibilities are ahead of our times. Practically everything is possible here: whole fleets of autonomous trucks are waiting to hit the road, and the idea of building taxi services on autonomous vehicles occupies the minds of many business people.

Autonomous cars and legal systems, Business Insider, Norbert Biedrzycki

It turns out, however, that the main barrier that will block change on the world’s roads for a long time to come will be insufficient legal regulation. An autonomous car is not only about comfort and – as numerous statistics show – greater road safety compared with having people behind the wheel. It also requires serious changes to traffic management and traffic lights. Optimising traffic in the future may mean integrating engine data, video camera images and signals collected by traffic lights at intersections.

Imagine an algorithm based on deep learning that statistically analyses the traffic at a given intersection and decides that a section of road should open a few seconds earlier than usual. And after that decision an accident happens. Who is responsible for it?

Autonomous vehicles on the roads also pose serious dilemmas for local authorities. An autonomous vehicle that drives more safely may also become more efficient. This may lead to a situation in which revenue from municipal car parks, which may empty, becomes a problem.

Controversies related to the automation of road traffic do not concern only cars and trucks. Drones are becoming the machines of our age, and in the future there will be autonomous ships and aircraft controlled from computer consoles. If we add the fact that more and more autonomous transporters will move goods around factories, the situation becomes even more complex and interesting.

The machine as a responsible entity

I have no doubt that liability for a product and liability for its use will become one of the most pressing legislative issues.

Where the intentionality of actions that interfere with the social order becomes relevant, algorithms must become participants in the legal and judicial spectacle. After all, behind every action of a program there is some human intention. While I can imagine appropriate legal provisions and solutions that satisfy all parties here, I still find it hard to imagine effective legislation in the face of the challenges that will arise with the spread of deep learning, a technology that gives machines a high degree of agency.

Can such a machine, capable of deciding how to improve its own performance, be treated by society as an entity with legal responsibility?

I do not want to, and cannot, settle how real the danger is that artificial intelligence will gain agency or become independent of humans. This issue is discussed today by specialists and by the main players in technology business – Elon Musk among them. I wonder whether, in the face of such a potential danger, one legislative solution might be universal certification of devices and algorithms put into circulation. But is certifying artificial intelligence logistically possible?

In my view, it is no longer enough to be aware that reality has accelerated and legal codes are ageing at lightning speed. Politicians, legislators and lawyers today bear great responsibility for the changes that can or should be made. If ordinary citizens are to feel safe and enjoy their contact with sophisticated technology, they must be protected. They should be completely certain that in a court case with them on one side and an algorithm on the other, the human being and human rights will prevail.

Autonomous cars and legal systems, Business Insider, Norbert Biedrzycki

The full article (in Polish) can be read at this link.

Related articles:

– A machine will not hug you, but it may listen and offer advice

– Can machines tell good from evil?

– Only God can count as fast: the world of quantum computers

– Machine learning. Computers are no longer babies

– How machines reason

Read next

  1. Politicians and AI. Can national strategies succeed?

    Politicians and AI. Can national strategies succeed

  2. We will reach a robotic sexual paradise. But will it make us happy?

  3. FORBES: Will robots begin to sin? Humanity will soon have to make unequivocal decisions

    My article in FORBES published 28th of August 2017. Algorithm-based technologies, machine learning and process automation have come to a point in their development where morality-related questions and answers may seriously affect the development of all of our modern technologies and even our entire civilization.