What sets an outstanding leader apart from a merely average one? The way they make decisions!

My article in BrandsIT Magazyn, 2 February 2019.
Link to the magazine. My article is on page 44.
-

Page 44 -

Page 45 -

Page 46
The full article:
According to various estimates, each of us makes from several dozen to several hundred decisions a day. We make most of them without reflection and automatically. They require neither special competence nor sacrifice, and they carry no risk of serious consequences. In many situations, decision-making in organisations is also based on routine and practically automatic actions. But every leader has, at some point in their career, faced a situation in which they felt that a decision would have serious consequences for the organisation. Such key moments reveal a leader’s ability to deal with the complexity of a problem and the many factors that must be taken into account at decisive moments. The most important choices made in management are influenced by stress, the leader’s experience and competence, analytical skills, the ability to control emotions, the ability to process large amounts of information quickly and the ability to think long-term.
Each of these elements plays its part, but their sum cannot be fully measured. That is why I would call making key decisions a balancing act between knowledge and ignorance, intuition and reason, certainty and its absence. A well-known saying by the American management theorist Aaron Wildavsky, active in the 1980s, illustrates this view. He pointed to a paradox: the leader of any organisation will never have the full set of necessary information, because part of it is lost at the “entrance” to the organisation and part is filtered inside it. If the leader tries to reach the original sources of information, they will be overwhelmed. If they rely on the information that reaches them, they will be misled. It looks rather like stalemate.
It is hard, so it is good
All the theoretical models of the decision-making process – and there are a great many of them – have much in common. The simplest describe an important sequence of events: we identify the problem, analyse it, develop possible solutions and then choose the best one based on our priorities or capabilities. Of these simple descriptive models, I am most persuaded by the one that sees decision-making as nothing more than choosing among available alternatives, always accompanied by weighing the benefits and costs of each option. But even in such a simple view, it is easy to find the critical moment, because the alternatives we see may carry a similar balance of costs and benefits. And then nothing counts except intuition based on experience. Even here, though, I see an optimistic solution, well described by Peter Drucker. In his view, you simply cannot wait too long: with an important decision, you rarely have 100 percent of the information needed to make a good one, and if you delay too long, you have a different problem – you have to start all over again. That is the dilemma of the indecisive decision-maker. In other words, at the top of the list of forbidden behaviours for a leader is procrastinating or running away from decisions. In my experience, no decision is often the worst decision of all.
A few simple techniques
Even at the most complicated moment, as a leader I am not acting in a vacuum and I do not start from zero. If I practise open leadership based on partnership and dialogue with people, I can count on information flowing from my environment: help, verification of my wrong assumptions, warning signals or signs of support. If I do not follow an authoritarian model of leadership, the chances that my choices will not be a mistake increase, because they rest on the knowledge of many. In addition, in a modern organisation I also have access to all kinds of data, including historical analyses, which let me assess whether my decisions make sense and how likely they are to produce positive results.
It also seems sensible to me to draw up a handy list of principles that a leader will follow at critical moments. For example, when making a decision, I first choose the actions that I believe will give the best result based on what I know here and now (that is, I cut off the process of endlessly multiplying data). Second, I stay alert to traps – in my thinking, my assumptions and my reasoning. I check that I am not confusing causes with effects. Third, as a rule and to the very end, I broaden my perspective by listening carefully to others. Fourth, I make sure I have all the key information available at the time, and all the analytical tools I could gather. And importantly, I do not make decisions based on momentary emotions, which should never influence decisions with long-term consequences. Perhaps most important of all, I make decisions based on experience (my own, my colleagues’ or the whole organisation’s). And I have the courage to admit mistakes when I know I have made them. This is of course not an exhaustive, universal primer, and it will not make sense for everyone. But I think every leader can build their own useful list of effective practices.
Automation in decision-making
Any reflection on decision-making requires at least a sketch of the automation of decision processes, because advancing automation does not spare this area either. In the context of the popular trend of using artificial intelligence, all decision-making processes are taking on a new dimension. It is a broad and very interesting subject that really needs a separate text, so I will only signal a few thoughts here. Today’s technological tools based on algorithms, machine learning and deep learning allow machines and algorithms to make an increasing number of key decisions. The leader, the whole organisation and the customer can all benefit directly. The huge data sets organisations have today make it possible to create many analytical and operational models, which are becoming useful and increasingly indispensable tools for managers and specialists in sales, marketing, logistics, production and finance. Digital ecosystems already operate globally, made up of products, services and a constant exchange of information at the interface of people, organisations and algorithms. It is in such ecosystems that the modern organisation moves, and its market success depends largely on processing information effectively. The concept of real-time analytics assumes that today’s leader will have access to more and more algorithm-based tools to support decision-making.
The customer and the leader
One of the main beneficiaries of today’s technological development is the customer. With mobile devices that give unlimited access to the internet, customers can comfortably postpone purchasing decisions. The computer in their hand lets them compare offers and prices and gives them complete freedom to work out what is attractive to them. Customers’ decisions are therefore increasingly rational and less and less emotional.
Knowing this, today’s leader is increasingly aware of how important constant contact with data on customers’ movements in digital space is. I think this element creates an entirely new quality and will increasingly influence management’s decision-making. Today, risky decisions are those that take into account all customer behaviour available from every possible source, including social networks, geolocation data, the films they watch and the IoT devices in their homes. The leader’s traditional intuition, experience and decision-making temperament gain an entirely new context here. Whether my decision was right will be shown by the next, lightning-fast report on the behaviour of customers who encountered that decision on their mobile devices. The customer will give me instant feedback through their purchasing decision or the data from their smartphone, and I, as a leader, must use it to make my next decision better.
Related articles
– Between good and evil: a few reflections on ethical leadership
– Automation will not destroy every desk
– Uncertainty has its charm: who is a leader in the digital economy
– The leader: from dictator to partner


