Between good and evil: a few reflections on ethical leadership

The days when a company boss’s authority was untouchable are gone for good. Today, at the head of an organisation, I can count on market volatility, inflated employee expectations, a lack of customer enthusiasm, tough investor demands and the struggle to convince bloggers and journalists that I am doing worthwhile things.
So what does doing “the right things” for an organisation mean today, as opposed to doing “things right”? Can an effective leader’s strategy include a mechanism that allows a quick choice between good and evil? Leading a group of people today, I have perhaps the proverbial five minutes to convince them that I am right, or to win them over to the business I am developing. If I want to succeed, I must be guided by a value system that is clear – above all to me. And, most importantly, I must lead by example: not just publish a list of the organisation’s values, but actually act and lead people in line with them.
Difficult questions
Every leader should ask themselves a few fundamental questions and answer them as soon as possible. This largely frees them from dilemmas that would make decisions harder. One question is how far a charismatic leader, with strong influence over others, may be subject to the temptation to manipulate. How can one keep a distance and a critical attitude towards oneself and avoid the trap of an inflated ego? Beyond these very individual and personal questions, every leader must resolve many business – but also ethical – dilemmas every day. Should I, following the principle of minimising costs (with the good and success of my company and my employees in mind), use the cheapest labour without caring about the life and social situation of subcontractors? If I work on the technologies of the future, should I sell them to anyone who wants to use them? Should I fulfil orders that will contribute to surveillance of others? When introducing tools that can increase efficiency (automation and robotisation), should I ignore employees who may lose their jobs and not think about the social good? When offering financial products, should I exploit customers’ gaps in knowledge and awareness? Should I take opportunities to discredit competitors and point out their shortcomings? These are just a few of the many questions every business leader today knows.
A leader’s code
There are more and more tools that clearly show the effectiveness of a company owner or a hired manager, but the “market” of ethical dilemmas is growing too. While it is relatively easy to set hard KPIs (key performance indicators) and financial targets for the organisation or for individual employees, it is harder to say whether the road to these indicators and targets is morally right.
I think every outstanding leader would endorse the statement that their work is a constant balancing act between what is necessary from the organisation’s point of view and their individual value system. None of us will find simple recipes showing what is good and what is bad in a given situation. But I think a good idea for the times we live in is to create, early enough, an individual code of principles and values to stick to. Such a “decalogue” is a guide in ambiguous situations, helps maintain consistency and helps resist temptations and avoid the traps of spontaneous choices. Difficult decisions will not go away, but with your own, well-thought-out ethical code they will certainly be easier to make. As a result, consistent decision-making based on clear values gives the organisation a chance to keep its image coherent and, above all, to base its development on healthy foundations. It lets the leader build an organisation that is friendly to employees and values them as people, and in the market it lets them build an authentic brand as a leader with greater ambitions than being a profit-generating machine.
Cheap ideas, apparent benefits
As I write these words, I have just read that one of the leading technology companies applied a peculiar policy designed to push customers to buy new phone models. According to journalists at a business website (the company did not distance itself from these reports), older models used technology that slowed the phone down. Can sabotaging your own products (what else can you call it?) be part of a sensible business strategy, a strategy for building a brand? One may ask: who is the leader who led a group of people who believed that such action would bring long-term benefits? That it brings short-term benefits – meeting sales plans and ruthlessly increasing profit – I can imagine.
But we live in times when customers’ opinions, their faith in a brand and their loyalty are priceless, built slowly and laboriously at great expense. A decision to pursue such a strategy is therefore risky from the point of view of the company’s long-term goals. With this one example, I am simply sketching one of the possible situations a modern leader finds themselves in. On the one hand, the dictatorship of financial targets, plans, spreadsheets, hard numbers and very specific shareholder expectations. On the other, the ruthlessly observant customer, whose opinions spread across the internet at the speed of light, and the very critical employee, sensitive to falsehood, who holds the employer to account for its promises on internet forums and professional networks.
The leader’s credibility
This example also shows another problem. The modern leader is a figure “in the crosshairs”. Placing them on a pedestal through media coverage may be an integral part of their strategy. We need public and investor relations, advertising, constant cooperation with traditional and electronic media and with bloggers. Today we must pursue our mission in full view of others – above all of customers, who pass quick verdicts on social media. Effective communication is worth its weight in gold today and deserves care. It is worth using every tool that makes it possible.
But we live in times of information chaos. Customers are tired of media messages, the media, chasing popularity, simplify their messages, and fake news ruins the reputations of people and companies. To protect an organisation’s reputation, you need a clearly articulated value system that is more than a hastily sketched media strategy. Very importantly, this is about consistency and credibility at every level. PR efforts are useless if colleagues and employees sense falsehood or distortion in the leader’s attitude, or see that his or her declarations do not translate into the daily life of the organisation. Credibility is a basic principle in business. Actions we consider good for the organisation must be based on the leader’s strong conviction that they are right, and also beneficial for the company.
The morality of algorithms
Writing about artificial intelligence, I have often expressed the view that it creates enormous opportunities for the development of modern societies. I have often said that I believe technological progress makes sense and will benefit us all. But I am aware that this process does not simplify ethical questions. Whether I like it or not, customers, citizens and people in general – often driven by irrational fear – will want to know whether they are safe when they use technology. A smart home stuffed with electronics, drones on the battlefield, facial recognition systems that make social control easier, bots acting as advisers, robots replacing workers, machines producing news – all this creates an ethically complicated reality. The challenge for today’s leader is to convince both customers and colleagues that new technology will not make harmful decisions on its own – that everything still really depends on us.
However, as someone has noted, technological systems are not free of bias and prejudice. One example is enough: algorithms used to predict behaviour based on analysing photos of faces and skin colour. On that basis, algorithms could influence credit, legal and social decisions – deciding the fate of individuals. As the leader of an organisation offering technology solutions, I must be aware that although I employ impartial programmers, the technology they create may malfunction or be used for unethical purposes. The leader’s role and ethical duty is to make themselves, their colleagues and their employees aware of all these mechanisms – not through persuasion, but by opening space for unrestricted discussion: discussion about what is good for us, for the company, for our customers and, ultimately, for society.
The human element
It may sound paradoxical, but in times of ever more intelligent technology, the role of people who have taken on leadership will matter more and more: their self-awareness, courage and ability to ask questions. These are essential and show that we retain our agency. In the face of all these doubts, today’s leader should remain open, including open to criticism. This may often mean stepping outside their comfort zone. But I believe that the free flow of ideas, openness to discussion and even initiating it are signs of care for others and a signal that my actions are based on real values. That despite many ethically complicated situations, as a leader I do everything I can to keep honesty, respect for others, social engagement and openness to dialogue unchanged.
I also believe that being a true leader has to be earned. You have to earn it through your attitude and the principles and values you hold. Being a leader does not end with talking about principles; you have to live by them. What is more, the role of leader is unfortunately often confused with a function: CEO, board member, director. Being promoted to such a role does not mean the person automatically becomes a leader.
Related articles:
– The leader: from dictator to partner
– Who will win and who will lose in the digital revolution?
– Can machines tell good from evil?
– How not to perish in the age of digitalisation: transforming companies effectively
– The fall of hierarchy: who really runs your company


