Counsel AI. How machines will change the law

My article published in Business Insider on 2 February 2019.
Reality often slips away from intellectuals, politicians and economists when it suddenly accelerates and leaves everyone behind. Lawyers poring over legal codes are in a similar position today. They must surely see that many situations arising from the arrival of machines, robots, computers and algorithms in our lives are not foreseen by legislation at all.
These are no longer (and will be even less so in the future) isolated cases in which a judge or an attorney cannot find support in the paragraphs written so far. Artificial intelligence can turn even the strongest legal systems upside down. And that is what will happen if the legal world does not realise that the sooner we start rewriting the codes, the better for all of us.
In the context of artificial intelligence these issues are pressing, difficult and often not even defined. I will point to a few areas that are particularly sensitive from the point of view of legislation – legislation that must finally face the fact that it will increasingly rule on artificial brains.
Law for artificial intelligence
One of the more popular opinions on the impact of artificial intelligence on our lives concerns work. Reports that robots will replace us in factories and offices stir emotions. “They will fire me soon, because a robot will cost them ten times less than me, it will not ask for a raise and it does not need a pension” – voices like this may multiply in the era of the announced fourth industrial revolution. The argument that eliminated jobs will be replaced by new ones is, for now, barely heard.
In highly automated South Korea there are already 437 robots per 10,000 manufacturing workers. In Japan there are 323, in Germany 232. In Germany, a robot working in the automotive industry costs the employer 5–8 euros, while a worker in the same position earns 35–40 euros.
Robotisation affects many other fields, such as medicine, marketing, media, IT services and even law. At the international news agency Associated Press, about 20 percent of news items and reports are written by applications. Their quality is no longer inferior to texts written by journalists.

Robotics and the labour market
Employees of media houses, where numerical data is key (and machines handle such data perfectly), also know that automation will significantly affect employment policy. What is more, the legal profession may also fear robots at work.
As the British newspaper The Guardian reports, an intelligent algorithm was put to work at the European Court of Human Rights. The program found a range of data in the analysed reports and then arranged it into specific patterns. On that basis it was able to predict the outcome of specific human cases with 79 percent accuracy. According to the paper, tens of thousands of jobs in the English legal sector will be automated over the next 20 years.
Looking coolly at the problem of robotisation and automation, it seems that legislative action on labour markets must be taken exceptionally quickly, and labour law faces many important and difficult decisions. Lawyers working in this field say that today’s codes are already essentially outdated and cannot keep up with reality.
More questions than answers
Should labour law regulate the share of jobs in a given industry or company that can be taken by machines? Will employers have the right to reduce human staff without limits in favour of machines? Will efficiency standards and targets be the same for machines and people? Will a machine be able to perform managerial duties? Do I have the right to refuse an instruction from my employer if I know it was generated by a machine? Who will be liable for potential damage caused by a machine – the programmer, the head of the department, the owner of the company? Will governments be obliged to decide which industries, and how, should be protected from excessive robotisation?
I think that lawyers who already work on Industry 4.0 – industry with the progressive social integration of people and machines – can probably count on overtime in their law firms.
Littler Mendelson P.C., one of the largest law firms in the world specialising in labour law, has a dedicated team dealing with robotics and artificial intelligence. In short, legislative processes in this area will develop dynamically, and the advantage of markets based on cheap labour will melt away as robotisation and automation progress.

Legal questions about copyright will become more complicated as algorithms become more present in media services and across the internet.
Creators – writers, musicians, journalists – must prepare for times in which the presence of creative machines, with their ability to produce texts, music, screenplays and even paintings or photographs, will be a fact. Questions about the status of a work and of its author are becoming increasingly complicated in this context, and the copyright law of many countries is not ready for them.
Recently, news spread around the world of Facebook’s decision to shut down algorithms that had begun to use their own language, developed independently of their programmers. This mechanism of self-improvement, using deep learning techniques that allow computer programs to learn on their own, may have many legal consequences.
If a bot set up to answer customers’ questions is able to create content on its own, who will be responsible for it? If any machine-generated content misleads me, causes lasting damage to my health or harms my business, whom can I sue? How will we treat plagiarism of human works created by intelligent devices? When I buy a work – a painting, for example – will I have to deal with a blurred notion of originality and doubts about who its author is?
The full article (in Polish) can be read at this link.
Related articles:
– A machine will not hug you, but it may listen and offer advice
– Can machines tell good from evil?
– Only God can count as fast: the world of quantum computers


